Workflow And Reengineering International Association

 

READ MORE ABOUT...


 

WORKFLOW COMPARATIVE STUDY 2004

Expanded 2004 edition with Business Process Management (BPM) vendors

 


The 2004 edition incorporates major reviews: 

  • SAP WebFlow, the SAP production workflow solution deployed together with its ERP applications  
  •  i-Flow workflow engine with dynamic changes capabilities by Fujitsu, all in Java.
  •  FlowMind workflow and BPM offer from Akazi, Developed in Java, with a Java API, and JSP forms generation..
  • Staffware with its new server optimized for pass through processing performances,  and an advanced process monitor to manage processes.
  • FileNet P8 BPM Suite, a P8 server and technologies based BPM product merging capabilities of Panagon Workflow ease of use and Visual Workflo production
  • COSA Workflow (the Baan workflow engine) with its new EAI-oriented features
  • enhanced versions of the Dolphin entry-level product and TeamWARE Flow from Fujitsu, 
  • WebSphere MQ Workflow (former MQSeries Workflow)  tightly integrated with WebSphere services, and with former Hollosofx business process analysis and monitoring tool.
  •  TIBCO InConcert with a new process definition tool able to define  activities in the form of IntegrationManagers' choreographies  
  • W4 Internet enterprise workflow  and its new W4 Studio business process analysis tool.
  • TeamWARE Flow and DOLPHIN from TeamWARE Group, WXF and Enterprise Workflow from eiStream, SERfloware from SER, and bizflow 2000 from Handysoft are out of the 2003 edition.. They are part of the 2001 edition (revision 2002) which can be ordered separately.

"Our research indicates the beginning of a concentration  of the Workflow industry around two categories of players: large EAI or ERP vendors for which a Workflow & BPM offer is more and more considered as strategic; and dynamic and independent workflow vendors building on a long experience of successful projects. The market will be less and less open to newcomers." says Martin Ader, researcher and industry analyst.


READ MORE ABOUT...


For IT Directors,   Architects, Consultants, Analysts, Workflow vendors, VAR Product Marketing and Sales Directors, this report provides a comprehensive framework for comparing workflow engines and products. 

It includes a competitive analysis of workflow products developed by Akazi, COSA Solutions, FileNET, Fujitsu , IBM,  SAP, Staffware, TIBCO, and W4.

Akazi Technologies, FlowMind

COSA Workflow

Filenet P8 BPM Suite

 
handys.gif (2691 octets) ser.gif (2696 octets) SAP, WebFlow  
Staffware Process Suite w4.gif (4015 octets) W4

READ MORE ABOUT...

ORDER FORM


DELIVERY
Electronic version is delivered by email immediately upon payment; 
contains multiple spreadsheets to score other products

8% discount available for WARIA, and WfMC members

PREVIOUS EDITIONS WERE SOLD IN THE  29 COUNTRIES, FIVE CONTINENTS ...
NORTH AMERICA CANADA, USA
SOUTH AMERICA CHILE, ARGENTINA
ASIA TAIWAN, KOREA, JAPAN, INDIA, SINGAPORE,
AFRICA SOUTH AFRICA
MIDDLE EAST ISRAEL, TURKEY,  SAUDI ARABIA
AUSTRALIA AUSTRALIA, NEW ZEALAND, NEW CALEDONIA
EUROPE EU , UK and EASTERN EUROPE
IN ALL INDUSTRIES
Utilities Air carrier, Post Offices, Telephone Operators, Airports, ....
Manufacturing Electronics, Motors, Car, Computers, ...
Finances Banks, Credit, Insurance,  ....
Government State, Local,  Air Force, Labor Department,   Coast Guard, ...
Retail Distributors, Clothing, Machinery, ....
EDP providers Software houses, Software Vendors, VAR, Computer Manufacturers, Integrators, Consultants ...
Energy Petroleum, Gas, Electricity, Nuclear power, ...
Communication Publishers, DotCom's, TV, Radio, ....
Health Pharmaceutical, Hospitals  ....
SELECTED QUOTES
Technical Architect in a financial services group " Your classification of workflow applications is really valuable and the best I have come across up to date. Your evaluation approach and detail is impressive "
ENGLAND: Tony Hendley, Technical director, Information Management & Technology " This is an extremely valuable analysis as, in addition to the nine products evaluated, the criteria can be used to evaluate any WFM software package "....." The (volume 3 ) study provides much detailed analysis which is well worth the price of the study on its own "..." Overall, the study is worth its weight in gold, It would save any project team weeks of work.. "..." That is good value for money when you consider how long it would take to collect anything near this amount of information "
GERMANY: Computerwoche A detailed description and summary of the Workflow Comparative Analysis by Martin Ader, from W&GS.
FRANCE: Sabine Bohnke, 01 Informatique "Progiciels, comment s'y retrouver dans le flot des workflow" .." Pour faire son marché, une étude de W&GS compare neuf moteurs sur la base de douze critères. .. Ils ont le mérite de définir une segmentation de l'offre qui tend à prouver que le produit universel n'existe pas " (To go shopping, a W&GS study compares 9 workflow engines on twelve criteria. .....their merit is to define a market segmentation which tends to prove that the universal product does not exist)
FRANCE: Cédric Nicolas, Eric Bricier , Informatique Magazine, "Dans son étude comparative, le consultant Martin Ader a noté, suivant 247 critères, neuf des principaux moteurs de workflow " (In its comparative study, the analyst Martin Ader scored, out of 247 criteria, nine of the main workflow engines)
EUROPE: Document World, "Workflow has grown into a mature software business domain with recognized potential for increasing organisation's efficiency, productivity and quality of services. But it still remains too much a concept under which different implementations find a convenient marketing umbrella. Suppliers who attract potential buyers without giving them a clear perspective won't contribute to making workflow an acceptable technology. Users need to have a means of being able to select from over a hundred product offerings available today. Martin Ader takes the challenge and analyses seven workflow engines."
2003 EDITION SAMPLE You can receive a pdf sample with some 20 pages extracted from Volumes 1, 2 and 3 with full Tables of Content from each volume. Click here
 A Unique report

This study's characteristics make it a must for anyone involved in developing a workflow strategy or with a role in the product selection and purchase decision.

  • It is a comparative study where each product is analyzed and ranked using the same check-list.
  • It is a detailed study that looks at 200 features, grouped into 12 criteria. Each item is scored for each products : more than 2 000 individual scores !
  • It is an in-depth study, going into the smallest details of the technical documentation of each product.
 Save days to months

For the price of a day of high level consulting you will save:

  • days of work by reading the management summary providing three clear and concise articles.
  • weeks of work with the comprehensive criteria definition, with a detailed justification of each of the 200 features. It will form the basis for comparing other products should you need them.
  • months of work by going through the comparative study discussing the implementation of each item for each product. This is based on the compilation of more than 10,000 pages of product documentation.

READ MORE ABOUT...

ORDER FORM


Who Needs this Report?

  • IT Directors and IT Architects who have to select workflow products to support today's demanding business needs of their organizations.
  • Workflow Consultants who need to have the best possible information to assist their customers in taking strategic decisions.
  • Workflow Market Analysts who always need a fresh perspective on workflow to enrich their market and product knowledge.
  • Product Marketing Directors of Workflow Vendors who have a need for comprehensive competitive analysis. This report does just that, giving them more time to concentrate on their key business: sales and marketing.
  • Sales Directors of Workflow Distributors and Value Added Resellers (VARs) who need to position their products against other offerings when bidding for projects. This report will give them a tool for quantitative and qualitative analysis.

 Packaging

Criteria Definition (Volume II) alone: Should you want just to compare other products, Volume II alone will provide you, at a reasonable cost, the whole product checklist from which you can instantly build your own shopping list.

Paper copy: Three volumes of quality printing, in full color.

Single user electronic and paper copy: Acrobat formatted color documents with hyper-links to vendor's webs. Password protected for single user and delivered with a paper copy.

Company license and paper copy: includes the electronic copy, the paper copy, and a license to distribute them to full time employees of the contracting company.

Each electronic copy includes your personal decision support system tool: Multiple spreadsheets allow you to add and score other products, tune weights to your own needs, instantly update 12 radar charts and 24 bar charts.

ORDER FORM


 About The Author

Martin Ader

16 years' of in-depth experience in workflow research and development, competitive analysis, and consulting.

Martin Ader set up and managed the Bull Workflow research team in 1987. The team was later transferred to Wang  Software (now Eastman Software), where Martin Ader became responsible for European Workflow Marketing. In 1996, he created his own consultancy firm, Workflow & Groupware Stratégies (W&GS). Martin Ader represents W&GS (a Full Member) at the WfMC steering committee with voting right. Ader participates in the Workflow and Reengineering International Association (WARIA) and is WfMCs' France Chapter Chair. He has published books, articles, papers, and participates to conferences in Europe, USA and Asia. Martin Ader runs intensive workshops on workflow engines selection world-wide, and has workflow projects consulting assignments in France, England and USA.


READ MORE ABOUT...

ORDER FORM


 
BOOKSTORE
ORDER HERE
 

New Book

BPMN Modeling and Reference Guide


Two Best Sellers - One Special Price!
Retail $114.95
Huge 39% Discount.
Pay only $69.95 for both BPMN books in one bundle.
You Save $45.00.


BPMN Edición digital en español
Precio: $49.95
Comprar


BPM Excellence Awards Publications

A Member of: 
Copyright © 1993 - 2014 Workflow And Reengineering International Association
All rights reserved.
Last modified: July 15, 2014